Arthurstone Library

Dundee Town Council adopted the Free Libraries Act in 1866 being the first town in the UK to do so. Support for the free libraries stated that for a cost of only one penny in the pound on the rates they would both “diminish crime and promote intelligence.”

Practical support came from a gift from Dr. Andrew Carnegie of “£37,000 being £11,000 for the central reading room and £6.500 for each of the four branch libraries” on the understanding that the sites for these buildings would be provided free of charge. The Arthurstone branch, the first of the new Carnegie libraries, cost considerably more than its allocation so it was hoped that the cost could be recouped from the other three.

In the Autumn of 1902  Andrew Carnegie visited Dundee and took the opportunity to inspect the plans of  the Arthurstone Branch and expressed his admiration of the elevation and internal arrangements”. At about the same time an offer of £1,500 for the purchase of the site from Miss Symers was accepted.

At the beginning of 1903 contracts amounting to nearly £5,000 were awarded for the construction of the new library.

In 1904 it was suggested the name the Symers Branch of the Carnegie Branch Library be given to the soon to be completed Arthurstone Library maintaining the names of the donors who had made the library possible, but it was finally decided that the outside of the building would simply bear the words “Public Library” but panels in the hall would record the names of both Dr Carnegie and Miss Symers.

Soon after opening the members of the Libraries Committee and not only pronounced themselves highly satisfied with the premises but found them superior to the central library in the Albert Institute.

When it came to appointing a caretaker the Committee decided that in view of the large amount of floor needing to be cleaned it was best to have someone under 45 years of age.

Dundee Free Libraries rules for books, giving readers 10 days to complete their book and a fine of one penny for every two days beyond that time

The new libraries didn’t meet with universal approval. As is so often the way it was the paying for them that was the downside. This was neatly summarised in a letter to the Dundee Evening Telegraph in January 1904 –  “I am a poor old widow woman and keep lodgers for a living. My rent is £20 and I have to pay 1½d in the pound to help my lodgers to get books to read using extra gas to do so. When the tax is raised to 2d per pound I’ll just need to go to the Poorhouse. Did Mr Carnegie mean to grind the life out if poor widow women when he gifted the money to the Library.”

 The Arthurstone Library was an immediate success. The value of a library service, though, is almost always at the mercy of statistics. These naturally tend to fluctuate. One time when the figures showed a decline fingers were pointed at there being too many cinemas. Another difficulty came with the introduction, firstly to Arthurstone, of the open-access system. This proved just a little too open to begin with with much borrowing of books and not so many returns. One parcel of ten books was found lying in a public park and others discovered on a dung heap. Another issue was the pilfering of magazines, the remedy for which, one reader suggested, was the use of a periscope.

The library’s solution was to present the magazines in a padlocked folder. There was also a moral problem with the newspapers being used as an aid to gambling. The answer was to obliterate all news relating to horse or greyhound racing by use of a roller which would carry the message ‘Obliterated by order of the Committee’. On occasion though the Committee were less prohibitive: Merry-go-rounds had been installed on waste ground close to Arthurstone library with the potential to bother readers. The Lord Provost, though, felt that they could not have too much merriment.

Through the 30s, 40s and 50s the library co-existed with its cinema neighbours, The Picture House and The Broadway, which together formed the cultural heart of Stobswell. Arthurstone Library has watched its cinema competitors and their successors, the bingo halls, come and go. Arthurstone Library has seen off the competition.

Comments are closed.